THE CHRISTMAS TINGLE TEST: ARE BRANDS CREATING MAGIC OR JUST SELLING IT?

Inside the Industry Series

There is something quite special about the Christmas advert. For years, the arrival of the big festive campaigns has become part of the countdown to Christmas. We look forward to them, talk about them, share them and, occasionally, remember them long after the decorations have come down.

But has something changed?

Every year, the productions seem to get bigger, the budgets more ambitious and the pressure on brands to create the advert everyone is talking about becomes greater. Familiar characters return, celebrities are brought in, childhood memories are revisited and emotional stories are carefully constructed to make us laugh, smile or reach for the tissues.

Yet there is a question worth asking: are brands still creating the magic of Christmas, or are they becoming so focused on selling it that they risk losing what made these adverts special in the first place?

That was the debate we explored in our latest TFTT films. Are brands commercialising Christmas to the point where the magic is being lost? Can you sell Christmas without losing the emotion? And, looking across this year's campaigns, which adverts have actually made us feel something?

It is a debate worth having because Christmas advertising occupies a unique position in retail. It is one of the few times of the year when advertising becomes part of the wider cultural conversation. People have their favourites, compare campaigns and form strong opinions about which brands have got it right.

The commercial stakes are significant, too. The Advertising Association and WARC forecast that UK advertising investment will reach £14bn in the final quarter of 2026, up 8.2% year on year. Nearly a fifth of annual advertising expenditure is concentrated in November and December. This is a major investment by businesses competing for customers at one of the most important trading periods of the year.

There is also evidence that people genuinely value these campaigns. Research from Credos, the Advertising Association's think tank, found that 63% of UK adults who celebrate Christmas say festive advertising helps put them in the Christmas spirit. Among 18 to 24-year-olds, that rises to more than 70%.

So there is clearly an appetite for Christmas advertising. But that does not mean every campaign gets it right.

For retailers, the challenge is to find the balance. Christmas advertising has a job to do. It needs to build awareness, create desire, support products and ultimately help sell. There is nothing wrong with that. The question is whether the audience feels they are being sold to, or whether the brand has created something they actually want to watch.

The strongest campaigns manage to do both. They make us feel something, but they also give us a reason to remember the brand behind the story. The weakest risk becoming expensive entertainment, where the character, celebrity or production is remembered but the retailer itself is lost.

That is why nostalgia, familiar characters and big budgets are not automatically good or bad. They can be powerful tools, but they need a purpose. A recognisable character should help tell a story. A celebrity should add something to the brand. A beautiful production should make the idea stronger. None of them can replace a clear creative idea.

Perhaps that is the real test of a Christmas advert: not simply whether it makes us feel something, but whether that feeling belongs to the brand.

WHAT MAKES A CHRISTMAS ADVERT WORK?

For our TFTT Top Five, we have looked beyond the size of the production, the famous faces and the amount of attention a campaign has generated. We have judged the adverts against five questions.

Emotional connection: Does it make us feel something, whether that is warmth, humour, excitement, nostalgia or a genuine sense of Christmas?

Storytelling: Is there a clear idea and a story worth watching, or is the campaign relying on a familiar face, character or soundtrack to carry it?

Brand authenticity: Does it feel true to the brand? Could another retailer have made exactly the same advert, or is there something distinctive about the business behind it?

Distinctiveness: Does it bring something fresh to an increasingly crowded Christmas advertising season?

Commercial relevance: Does the story connect naturally to what the business offers? Does it give people a reason to remember the brand, understand its proposition or consider its products?

These criteria do not mean every campaign has to do exactly the same thing. One advert might be particularly powerful emotionally, another might be an outstanding expression of brand identity, while another may connect its products and commercial proposition more effectively.

What matters is the overall balance.

We are judging the creative and the commercial thinking behind the campaigns, not claiming to have measured their sales performance. Views, likes and attention can tell us whether an advert has attracted interest. They do not, on their own, prove that it has changed customer behaviour or delivered a return on investment.

With that in mind, here are the five Christmas adverts that stood out to us this year.

TFTT'S TOP FIVE CHRISTMAS ADVERTS OF 2026

1. M&S - THE HOME OF CHRISTMAS

M&S gets our number one spot because it understands something that is easy to overlook: the strongest Christmas advertising can entertain people while doing a very clear job for the business.

The campaign stars James Norton as an undercover Father Christmas, with Lucy Punch as Mrs Claus and Katherine Jenkins providing a specially recorded version of Heaven Is a Place on Earth. Encouraged by Mrs Claus, Santa leaves the North Pole, changes his appearance and heads into the real world to experience Christmas for himself.

It is a simple idea, but it gives M&S plenty of room to bring its offer into the story. The campaign brings Food, Fashion, Home and Beauty together in one Christmas campaign for the first time since 2017. We see festive food, gifts, clothing and the wider experience of preparing for Christmas, rather than one category being asked to carry the entire campaign.

That is the real strength. M&S has a broad proposition, but customers do not necessarily think about all those categories together. Christmas gives the retailer a natural opportunity to show how they fit into the same occasion. The advert makes that connection feel part of the story, rather than a corporate message about the breadth of the business.

The use of Father Christmas is familiar, and the cast brings star power. But the campaign does not rely on either alone. The characters help tell the story, while the products give it a commercial purpose.

M&S is not simply saying that it sells Christmas food or partywear. It is positioning itself as a retailer customers can turn to across the season, from the food on the table to the clothes, gifts and finishing touches.

For us, M&S gets the best overall balance of emotion, entertainment, brand personality and commercial relevance. It is not necessarily the most original idea in isolation, but it is the most complete piece of retail advertising in our selection.

2. DISNEY - THE INVISIBLE HORSE

Disney takes a very different route. The Invisible Horse is an original three-minute holiday short about Jack, a boy who starts to feel that he is too old for Christmas. An invisible horse enters his life and takes him on a journey that brings back his imagination and draws him closer to his family.

This is the most emotionally driven campaign in our five. It understands that the magic of Christmas is not really about the decorations, the presents or the characters we recognise. It is about the way we experience the season, particularly as children, and the memories we carry into adulthood.

There is a temptation for a brand such as Disney to rely on its existing intellectual property. Its characters are among the most recognisable in the world, and using them would have been an obvious way to secure attention. Instead, the campaign creates a new story and trusts the audience to connect with the idea.

That is a confident decision. It also feels true to Disney. Imagination, storytelling and the creation of worlds that audiences want to enter are central to the brand. The invisible horse is not just a Christmas gimmick; it is the device that allows the film to explore those themes.

Where Disney is particularly strong is emotional connection. It gives the audience a reason to care about Jack and his journey. The story reinforces the wider Disney brand without needing to turn the film into a product catalogue.

We have placed it second because its strength is less directly connected to a specific retail product or shopping occasion than M&S. That is not a criticism of the campaign. It is simply a distinction between an emotionally powerful brand film and a retail campaign that brings several product categories together.

Disney reminds us that sometimes the most effective way to sell a brand is to give people a reason to feel something about it.

3. BURBERRY - WRAPPED IN BURBERRY: CELEBRATING 170 YEARS

Burberry's campaign makes a different point: brands do not always need to borrow someone else's idea of Christmas. Sometimes they need to be more confident in their own identity.

Wrapped in Burberry: Celebrating 170 Years opens the doors of an English country house for a festive gathering. Set at Longleat House in Wiltshire and directed by Harmony Korine, the film features Pierce Brosnan and Fiona Shaw welcoming guests from the worlds of film, fashion and sport.

The campaign celebrates Burberry's history, but it is not simply a retrospective. The setting, the styling, the cast and the atmosphere create a distinctive world that feels connected to the brand. It draws on British heritage, fashion, craftsmanship and the idea of dressing up for an occasion.

It is important to recognise that Burberry is using celebrities and spectacle. That is not inconsistent with our criteria. The question is whether those elements serve the brand. Here, they help create the feeling of a particular kind of Burberry Christmas gathering. They are part of the identity the campaign is communicating.

There is also a commercial purpose. The film gives the brand a platform to present its clothing and accessories in an aspirational setting, while reminding audiences of the heritage behind the name. The wider festive offer, from outerwear and knitwear to accessories and gifting, sits naturally within that world.

That is what we particularly like about it. Burberry is not trying to outdo another retailer's sentimental advert or compete for the same familiar Christmas formula. It is leaning into what makes it distinctive.

We have placed it third because it is arguably the strongest of the five in terms of brand identity, but it is more about atmosphere, aspiration and occasion than a personal emotional story. It knows exactly what it wants to say about Burberry. Sometimes that is the strongest story a brand can tell.

4. NOT ON THE HIGH STREET - THE BIRDHOUSE

Not On The High Street has a much smaller stage to work with than the biggest retailers, but its campaign demonstrates the value of knowing what makes your business different.

The Christmas film, Christmas, Made With Love, centres on Ted, his Granny and a special robin. At the heart of the story is a personalised birdhouse made by MijMoj Design, one of the independent businesses on the platform. Other products from its partner community also appear throughout the film.

The birdhouse is more than a prop. It represents the thought behind a gift, the person who made it and the reason it matters to the recipient. That is exactly the territory Not On The High Street wants to occupy.

The business is built around independent makers, distinctive products and more personal gifting. Rather than simply telling customers that it offers something different, the campaign puts those makers and their products into the story.

That is a strong connection between the creative idea and the commercial proposition. The independent businesses are not hidden behind the platform. They are part of what makes the brand relevant.

There is also something valuable in the decision to give a small maker such a prominent role in a national Christmas campaign. The birdhouse was developed specifically for the film, and the wider campaign features products from across the platform's partner community. It demonstrates the potential reach of the marketplace and celebrates the people behind the products.

It may not have the scale or production ambition of M&S, Disney or Burberry, but that is not the point. Its strength is the personal nature of the story and the connection between the gift and the people involved.

It takes fourth place because the emotional and storytelling ambition is more modest than the campaigns above it. But its brand fit is particularly strong. It understands that for its customers, the thought behind a gift can be just as important as the gift itself.

5. SAINSBURY'S - THE BIG DELIVERY

Sainsbury's brings back the BFG for a third consecutive Christmas, giving the familiar character a new problem to solve.

This time, the giant is unwell and decides he is going to miss Christmas. Sainsbury's colleague Annie and delivery driver Fred set off through Giant Country with a van full of festive food to make sure he does not miss out on Christmas dinner.

The idea is straightforward and the emotional message is clear: nobody should be left out of Christmas. The BFG provides immediate recognition, while Annie and Fred give the story a human connection. The food is central to the journey and the eventual festive feast, with Sainsbury's Taste the Difference range playing a prominent role.

There is a commercial strength here. Sainsbury's is not simply placing products around a well-known character. The food delivery is the reason for the adventure, and the retailer has a natural role in bringing the story to its conclusion.

But there is a wider point about the Sainsbury's business that should not be overlooked. Christmas is not just a food occasion. It is a family occasion, and the campaign helps create a broader festive mindset that can extend across the retailer's offer.

That matters for Tu. Its Christmas range includes festive clothing, partywear, children's products and matching family nightwear. The family gathering, Christmas morning and the traditions around the season are natural occasions for Tu to serve. The BFG campaign helps Sainsbury's occupy that wider Christmas space, creating an opportunity for the group to connect the festive food shop with other seasonal needs.

We should be clear: the BFG advert itself is food-led. Tu is not a featured part of the film. The opportunity is in how Sainsbury's can use the wider festive campaign to support the whole Christmas shopping mission, with Tu playing its part through its own products, marketing, online activity and in-store presentation. The emotional territory of family, togetherness and Christmas morning is relevant to both businesses.

The question is whether the BFG can keep doing the job. This is the third consecutive year the character has featured in Sainsbury's Christmas advertising. That continuity can build recognition and make the campaign feel like an annual fixture. But familiarity can become repetition if the story does not keep moving forward.

There is a balance to strike between building a recognisable platform and giving audiences a fresh reason to watch. Sainsbury's has a clear emotional idea this year, but the format is now familiar.

It earns its place in our five because it connects a well-known character to a clear story and a relevant product offer. We have placed it fifth because the challenge of keeping the campaign distinctive is becoming more apparent. Recognition is valuable, but it cannot do all the work.

THE BIGGER QUESTION FOR RETAILERS

Looking across these five campaigns, there is no single formula for a successful Christmas advert.

M&S shows how a retailer can bring a broad offer together around one story. Disney demonstrates the emotional power of original storytelling. Burberry makes the case for knowing your own identity. Not On The High Street puts its independent makers at the centre of its proposition. Sainsbury's shows how a familiar character can support a strong seasonal message, while creating an opportunity to connect with a wider retail offer.

They are different approaches, but the common thread is that the creative idea has to belong to the brand.

That is where the commercial test becomes important. Views, likes and social engagement can tell us whether a campaign has attracted attention. They cannot, on their own, tell us whether people remember the retailer, understand what it stands for or are more likely to shop with it.

Those questions require a different level of measurement: brand recall, consideration, customer response and, ultimately, evidence of commercial impact. Without that evidence, it would be wrong to claim that one advert has driven more sales than another.

But we can judge whether a campaign gives the business a credible opportunity to build those connections. The strongest adverts in our selection do that in different ways. They give the audience something to enjoy, but they also give the brand a clear role in the story.

For retailers, that is the opportunity. Christmas advertising should sell. It should create demand, support product categories and give customers a reason to choose one business over another. There is nothing wrong with that. The mistake is assuming that a big budget, a famous face or a familiar character will automatically make people care.

The best campaigns understand the customer, know what the brand stands for and find a creative idea that brings the two together.

So, has the Christmas magic survived? We think it has. But it does not come from spending the most or following the same formula as everyone else.

It comes from knowing what makes your brand special, finding a story worth telling and giving people a reason to remember it.

It's not about who spent the most. It's about who made us feel the most.

The TFTT Top Five is an editorial selection based on emotional connection, storytelling, brand authenticity, distinctiveness and commercial relevance. It is not a ranking of independently measured sales performance or advertising return.

Next
Next

Oxford Street: Has the Mayor got it wrong?