TFTT FRIDAY REVIEW
The high street is fighting for relevance, businesses are struggling to create opportunities for young people, and retailers are heading into Christmas with margins under pressure. Three very different stories, but one common question: what does it take to build a successful retail industry?
Retail is approaching one of the most important periods of the year, but there are some bigger questions facing the industry beyond the Christmas trading figures. The way people shop continues to change, the economics of employing people are becoming increasingly challenging, and retailers are entering the busiest trading period of the year with pressure on both consumer spending and profitability.
These issues may appear unrelated, but they are all part of a much bigger conversation about the future of the industry. This week, we look at the changing role of physical retail, the responsibility and ability of businesses to create opportunities for the next generation, and why the real measure of Christmas trading will be what retailers make, not simply what they sell.
1. OXFORD STREET VS CARNABY STREET: WHAT DOES THE FUTURE OF PHYSICAL RETAIL LOOK LIKE?
Two of London's best-known shopping destinations, but two very different approaches to retail. Oxford Street is built around scale, with major international brands, flagship stores, department stores and an enormous range of choice. Carnaby Street offers something different, with a more curated environment, a distinctive identity and a shopping experience that feels more individual. Both have an important place in London's retail landscape, but they illustrate how different the proposition can be when it comes to attracting customers.
For years, the conversation around physical retail has been dominated by the growth of online shopping, with the suggestion that stores are gradually becoming less relevant. I think that is too simplistic. People still want to shop physically, but their expectations have changed. They want to discover brands, see and touch products, receive good service and experience something that goes beyond simply buying an item. Increasingly, they also want places that are worth spending time in, rather than just somewhere to complete a transaction.
Selfridges on Oxford Street provides a good example of how this can work in practice. Its proposition goes well beyond the brands and products on its shop floors. Restaurants, its food hall, personal shopping, events and brand experiences all give customers additional reasons to visit and spend time in the store. The shopping experience becomes part of the attraction, rather than simply the transaction. It is a good illustration of how a retailer can build a destination around its core offer, rather than relying on product and location alone.
Of course, not every retailer has the scale or investment available to Selfridges, nor should they try to replicate it. The lesson is about understanding the role of the physical store and what it can offer that online cannot. A flagship should bring a brand to life, create a connection with customers and contribute to the wider business, whether through brand awareness, customer acquisition, service or ultimately driving online and offline sales. Equally, landlords and shopping destinations need to think carefully about the mix of retailers, the environment they create and what will encourage people to make the journey.
There is also a commercial reality that cannot be ignored. Retail space is expensive, and every store needs to justify its place in the wider business. That means looking beyond the sales generated within the four walls and understanding the wider contribution a store makes to the customer relationship. The retailers and destinations that get this right will be those that understand why people visit them and give customers a reason to return.
Oxford Street and Carnaby Street do not need to become the same, and that is precisely the point. Their differences are part of their appeal. The future of physical retail isn't about choosing between online and stores; it is about making them work together while giving customers a compelling reason to experience a brand in person.
2. THE MILBURN REPORT: WHO GIVES THE NEXT GENERATION THEIR FIRST CHANCE?
Nearly one million young people in Britain are not in education, employment or training. The latest published ONS figures put the number at 981,000 people aged 16 to 24 in April to June 2026. It is a significant challenge, but there is another question that government needs to address: are its own employment policies making it harder for businesses to give young people their first job?
Alan Milburn's review, published this week, has brought youth employment firmly back onto the national agenda, and retail needs to be right at the centre of this conversation. For generations, retail has been one of the biggest entry points into working life. The first Saturday job, the first experience of dealing with customers, learning to sell, working as part of a team and taking responsibility are all experiences that can provide the foundations for a much bigger career. Retail is not simply a source of entry-level employment; it is an industry where people can develop, progress and build long-term careers.
However, the economics of employing people have changed considerably. In April 2025, employer National Insurance increased from 13.8% to 15%, while the threshold at which employers start paying it fell from £9,100 to £5,000. The British Retail Consortium estimates that increases in National Insurance and the National Living Wage have added £6.5 billion to retailers' employment costs in just two years. For an industry already dealing with pressure from rents, business rates, wages and increasingly competitive trading conditions, that is a substantial additional burden.
Milburn's review recognises this problem and proposes a five-year phased increase in the employer National Insurance threshold for workers aged 21 to 24, from £5,000 to £10,000, initially focusing on retail and hospitality. The recommendation is subject to the state of the public finances, so it is important to recognise that this is a proposal rather than a change businesses can currently rely on. Nevertheless, it acknowledges something important: the cost of employing people matters, particularly in sectors where part-time and entry-level roles are an important route into work.
There is a clear contradiction here. We want businesses to employ more young people, but we have also introduced measures that have made employing people more expensive. Of course, businesses have a responsibility too. They need to invest in training, create opportunities and give people the chance to prove themselves. But they can only do that if the commercial conditions allow them to recruit in the first place. If the cost of taking on an additional member of staff becomes increasingly difficult to justify, one of the first places businesses may look to reduce recruitment is at entry level.
The consequences could extend well beyond the immediate jobs market. If young people lose access to their first opportunities in retail, we risk removing one of the most accessible routes into employment, with all the experience, confidence and transferable skills that come with it. We should be encouraging more businesses to open that door, not making it harder for them to do so.
Retail has always been one of the industry's biggest training grounds. If government genuinely wants businesses to create more opportunities for the next generation, it needs to make sure the economics of employing people support that ambition.
3. THE CHRISTMAS TEST: ARE CONSUMERS READY TO SPEND, AND CAN RETAILERS MAKE MONEY?
Christmas is approaching, and retailers are entering one of the most important trading periods of the year. However, the latest economic figures provide a mixed picture of what lies ahead. This week, the Office for National Statistics reported that UK CPI inflation increased from 3.5% to 3.6% in October. At the same time, goods inflation increased to 3.5%, while clothing and footwear prices were 0.5% lower than a year earlier. For fashion retailers, that combination is worth looking at more closely.
Consumers are still dealing with pressure on household budgets, while the fashion market continues to face significant price competition. Promotions, discounting and the battle to attract customers are all influencing what people are prepared to pay. Retailers need to generate demand, but they also need to be careful about how they do it, particularly at a time when the cost of operating a business remains high.
Black Friday, Christmas and the January sales represent a significant opportunity to generate revenue, shift stock and finish the year strongly. But they also bring the temptation to discount heavily in pursuit of sales. The danger is that businesses become so focused on turnover that they lose sight of what they are actually making. A strong sales performance can look impressive on the surface, but if it has been achieved by sacrificing too much gross margin, the commercial outcome may be very different.
Consider a product with a £200 selling price and a £100 cost, using ex-VAT figures for simplicity. At full price, it generates £100 gross profit. Apply a 30% discount and the selling price falls to £140, leaving just £40 gross profit. In other words, a 30% reduction in the selling price has cut the gross profit by 60%. That is a significant difference and demonstrates why retailers need to understand the impact of discounting rather than simply looking at the additional sales volume it might generate.
This is particularly relevant in fashion, where buying decisions, stock availability, product mix, markdowns and the timing of promotions all have a direct impact on the final result. There is nothing wrong with promotional activity when it is planned and commercially justified. Clearing stock at the right time can release cash, create space for new product and reduce the cost of holding inventory. The problem comes when discounting becomes the default way to generate demand, rather than a considered part of the trading strategy.
Retailers need to understand what they are selling, the margin they are retaining and the contribution those sales are making to the business. It is also important to distinguish between revenue, gross profit and the final profitability of the business. Strong sales are important, but they do not automatically translate into a successful trading period if the margin has been eroded or the additional costs of generating those sales have outweighed the benefit.
This Christmas isn't just about how much retailers sell. It's about how much they actually make. The businesses that come through the trading period in the strongest position will be those that balance sales growth with disciplined buying, sensible stock management and control over discounting. Ultimately, that is the real test of Christmas trading.
TFTT Insider VIEW
These three stories may appear quite different, but they highlight some of the same challenges facing the industry. Physical retail needs to give customers a reason to visit, businesses need the confidence and financial flexibility to employ and develop people, and retailers need to focus on profitable growth rather than simply chasing sales.
There is a wider responsibility here too. Retailers need to keep evolving, brands need to understand what their customers value, landlords need to create destinations worth visiting and government needs to recognise the commercial realities businesses face. In particular, employment policy cannot be considered in isolation from the cost of employing people. If government wants businesses to invest, recruit and create opportunities, it has to ensure its policies support those ambitions rather than make them harder to achieve.
Retail remains one of the UK's most important industries. It creates employment, develops talent, supports communities and brings our towns and cities to life. There is enormous opportunity ahead, but realising it will require businesses and policymakers to make decisions that support sustainable growth rather than simply short-term objectives.
The question isn't whether retail has a future. It is whether the people making decisions today are creating the conditions for it to succeed tomorrow.
That's the conversation worth having.
TFTT INSIDE FASHION. NOT OBSERVING IT.